THE FURTHER MIS-ADVENTURES OF CLIFF BOOTH, Tarantino Should Have Left It in the Drawer

To understand the impetus behind The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth, the Quentin Tarantino-written, David Fincher-directed, Brad Pitt-starring sequel to Tarantino’s masterful Once Upon a Time… in Hollywood (a film that gets stronger every time I watch it), you need a little Tarantino lore.

Lore #1: As far back as his Pulp Fiction days, Tarantino has toyed with making sequels to his films. Throw a dart at his filmography and you’ll likely hit a follow-up he once told somebody he was working on: a prequel about the Vega Brothers, a spinoff of Inglourious Basterds, the Django Unchained sequel that became The Hateful Eight, and of course the big mama-jamma, Kill Bill: Volume 3. None of them ever came to fruition, though if you buy into his “shared movie-verse,” they’re almost all sequels to each other in some fashion.

Lore #2: Before this collaboration, Tarantino had been working on a screenplay called The Movie Critic. Not much is known about the story, or even whether he finished it. From what’s been reported, it was set in the late ’70s and centered on a critic modeled on a real-life writer for a porn magazine. Early chatter pegged Pauline Kael as the inspiration, but Tarantino has said otherwise. Many assumed it would be his famed “tenth and final film.” Then he scrapped it, and what emerged instead became his first produced sequel script.

Lore #3: Tarantino’s debt to Elmore Leonard is well documented, and it produced one of his other great works in Jackie Brown. Less discussed is his love of the Miami crime writer Charles Willeford. He doesn’t talk about it much now, but in the days leading up to Pulp Fiction, Tarantino openly admitted he was chasing the feel of Willeford’s shambling, discursive narratives, pocked with sudden, intense violence. Adapting one of the late author’s Hoke Moseley novels outright would probably have been gilding the lily.

You’d assume I’m coming to a point here. I am. A point you shall have.

About seven years after the events of Once Upon a Time…, Cliff (Pitt, looking oddly de-aged at times) works odd jobs. Most are of the bartending variety, but he’s also (groan) a projectionist at the Beverly Cinema, the theater Tarantino owns in real life. Those of you who did your homework and read Tarantino’s novelization of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood will recall that Cliff is a big cinephile (it’s a fun read, by the by), so the indulgence is forgivable. The Manson Family’s attack on the home of Rick Dalton, his best friend and the star he used to double for, left Cliff with a permanent limp that’s taken him out of the stunt game. That, and a reputation for probably killing his wife, will do it. So now Cliff lives with his elderly father, Gus (Peter Weller), in a Southern California apartment complex. His action these days is relegated to gig work and “doing favors for friends.” In the Hollywood-fixer sense, of course.

One of those friends turns out to be Charlie Peters (Scott Caan), a diminutive actor who has gotten himself into a tight spot. It involves another longtime acquaintance of Cliff’s (Carla Gugino) and a threat quietly looming in the background of the film. It’s up to Cliff, merciless killing machine that he is, to solve this seemingly insurmountable problem.

It’s a very straightforward plot. The trick is that it takes almost half the running time to get there. Which brings us back to our lore.

The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth is a pure hangout movie. If you enjoyed the stretch of Once Upon a Time… where Rick and Cliff basically provide DVD commentary over an episode of The F.B.I., or its many cutaways to career overviews with actors superimposed into archival footage, you’ll find plenty to enjoy here. But a hangout movie is only as good as the company, and the novelty that made it sing the first time curdles into indulgence here. For much of the running time, it’s Cliff building model airplanes with his father and chewing over Ralph Meeker’s refusal to blink. Or it’s Cliff playing doubles tennis with Charlie. Or it’s Cliff’s blossoming romance with his new paramour, Karen (Elizabeth Debicki), topped off with a demolition derby and revelations about the seedier side of our hero’s professional journey.

Here’s where Willeford comes home to roost. The most immediate problem is that Cliff doesn’t feel like the same character we met in the last movie. Instead, it’s as if he’s been recast as the knight-errant hero of a ’60s or ’70s paperback. Think Travis McGee or Matthew Scudder (he has a couple of traits from each), or, more to the point, the lead of a Willeford novel. Between that and the ever-expanding, moseying screenplay, the film plays like an outright tribute to that genre giant. But what works on the page drags on screen, and far too often the sag shows through, like a muscle car stuck in stop-and-go traffic. By the time the credits roll, you can’t stop counting the detours the trip could have skipped.

Worse, Cliff is never really challenged. Every woman he meets wants him, from doe-eyed barflies to world-weary actresses. Sure, by the end he’s been put through the physical wringer, but bruises and burns aren’t the same as stakes, and those all belong to other people. Cliff never has to doubt himself, change, or risk losing anything that matters to him. He’s an unbothered fixer drifting through everyone else’s crises. Neither Tarantino nor Fincher seems willing to test him in any way that counts, as if complicating their favorite creation would mean killing a darling.

Which brings us back to The Movie Critic. It’s abundantly clear that Debicki’s Karen carries a lot of that script’s DNA. As a study of craft, that’s interesting. As a viewing experience, it’s a problem, because the writer and director are plainly infatuated with this material, and it shows far too much. Did we really need an extended stretch of Karen expounding on the superiority of literature over popcorn fare? Or, artful as it is, a sequence where she attends the premiere of Looking for Mr. Goodbar? Mostly, it leaves you hungry to know what shape the original concept took. How refreshing would it have been for one of these to put a woman front and center, especially in a film this soaked in testosterone?

For our grand finale, we return to the question: did we need more Cliff Booth? It’s the same question the internet has chewed on for years. Do we need more adventures with the Bride? Is there more to say about Vince and Vic Vega? Pairing Fincher’s visual sensibility with Tarantino’s words has its own appeal. It’s a rare treat to watch a filmmaker filter that overbearing Tarantino style into something closer to their own. It worked wonders in True Romance, less so in From Dusk Till Dawn. Here, though, the match feels ill-formed. It’s as if Fincher, a noted perfectionist, loosened up so much that he landed on a pale impression of Tarantino, or even Shane Black. Only two things mark this as recognizably Fincher. One is some ugly digital cinematography (at times Pitt’s face looks as uncanny as Benjamin Button’s). The other is a single scene that’s jarring in its ruthlessness.

A director with a lighter touch would have made for a better match. Steven Soderbergh comes immediately to mind, though much of that is the delicious possibility of closing the Jackie Brown–Out of Sight loop.

A peek behind the curtain: while drafting this piece, the writer kept trying to type the film’s title and kept landing on The Further Mid-Adventures of Cliff Booth. He apologizes for leaning on Gen Z slang, but there’s something downright Freudian about that easy slip. This particular Mis-Adventure proves that Tarantino’s instinct to leave those sequel drafts in the drawer was the right one. If only he’d stuck with it.

 

Back to Top